If you’re a business owner in Illinois exploring affordable roofing options for your commercial property, you’ve likely come across roll roofing. Known for its quick installation and low cost, roll roofing is a popular choice for smaller commercial buildings and outbuildings. But just like any roofing system, it comes with both advantages and drawbacks.
In this guide, we’ll walk through the most important roll roofing pros and cons to help you decide if it’s the right fit for your business. And as always, ReCrafted Roofing Company is here to guide you with local expertise and honest advice.
What Is Roll Roofing?
Roll roofing, also known as mineral-surfaced roll roofing (MSR), is a material made from asphalt and fiberglass or felt. It comes in large rolls, usually 36 inches wide, and is applied in sheets to cover low-slope roofs.
This roofing type is often used for garages, storage buildings, and commercial structures with limited roof complexity. It’s fast to install, relatively lightweight, and provides basic protection, making it appealing to businesses on a tight budget.
Let’s break down the key roll roofing pros and cons that Illinois business owners should consider.
Pro: Budget-Friendly Roofing Solution
One of the biggest advantages of roll roofing is the price. It’s significantly more affordable than other roofing systems like TPO, EPDM, or metal roofing. This makes it an attractive option for small businesses or temporary structures.
If your building needs quick protection without a heavy upfront investment, roll roofing can be a practical starting point.
At ReCrafted Roofing Company, we’ve helped many local clients in Illinois manage costs while protecting their properties with reliable Roll Roofing options.
Con: Shorter Lifespan Than Other Roofing Systems
While the price is right, the lifespan is not as long as premium systems. Most roll roofing lasts about 5 to 10 years with proper care. In contrast, materials like EPDM or metal can last 20 to 40 years.
If you’re planning to occupy your building long-term or want a roof that lasts decades, this is a serious downside. As part of the roll roofing pros and cons, lifespan is something to weigh carefully, especially in Illinois where weather conditions can accelerate wear and tear.
Pro: Quick and Simple Installation
Roll roofing is easy to install, often completed in a single day. That means less labor time, less disruption to your business, and lower installation costs. It can be applied using nails, cold adhesive, or heat, depending on your roof type and needs.
This is ideal for businesses needing fast protection or planning a phased renovation.
Our team at ReCrafted Roofing Company often recommends Roll Roofing for time-sensitive projects or temporary commercial spaces in areas like Minooka, Joliet, and other parts of Illinois.
Con: Limited Design and Aesthetic Options
Unlike metal or single-ply roofs, roll roofing comes in limited styles and colors. It’s functional but not designed to be beautiful. For buildings where curb appeal matters, like retail shops or client-facing offices, this may be a drawback.
If appearance plays a role in your business image, this should be factored into your roofing decision.
Pro: Lightweight and Easy to Work With
Roll roofing doesn’t add much structural weight to your building. It’s a good choice for roofs that can’t support heavier materials. Plus, its flexible nature makes it easy to work around vents, pipes, and smaller architectural features.
This makes it particularly useful for older buildings or temporary expansions.
Understanding these roll roofing pros and cons can help you match your roofing choice with your building’s current condition and load-bearing capabilities.
Con: Prone to Damage in Extreme Weather
Illinois weather is tough; snow, hail, heat, and storms all come into play throughout the year. Roll roofing is more prone to cracking, tearing, and curling under these conditions compared to more durable systems.
If your building is in an exposed location or sees harsh weather, this vulnerability could lead to frequent repairs or early failure.
Local Experience Matters When Choosing Roofing
ReCrafted Roofing Company has worked with a wide range of businesses across Illinois, from small warehouses in Minooka to service shops in Plainfield. We understand what local roofs go through and how to pair the right system with the right building.
Roll roofing isn’t the perfect solution for every commercial property, but in the right setting, it offers value, speed, and functionality. That’s why we assess each roof individually and give honest recommendations that work with your timeline, your budget, and your long-term goals.
Whether you’re covering a workshop, a temporary retail unit, or a utility building, we’ll help you decide if Roll Roofing is a smart option, or if another system might suit you better.
Final Thoughts
Here’s a quick recap of the roll roofing pros and cons every Illinois business should know:
Pros:
- Affordable upfront cost
- Fast and simple to install
- Lightweight and flexible for older buildings
- Ideal for small or temporary structures
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan than premium roofing systems
- Not ideal for high-traffic or harsh-weather zones
- Limited visual appeal and style options
- May require more frequent repairs over time
Choosing the right roof isn’t about picking the cheapest option, it’s about finding the one that gives your business the best protection and performance for your needs. That’s where ReCrafted Roofing Company comes in. We combine local knowledge with quality craftsmanship to help Illinois business owners make confident, cost-effective roofing decisions.
by